Validity of Selective Tissue Tests for Knee Pathologies: An Evidence-to-Practice Review


  • Stephanie P. Ulshafer University of South Carolina
  • Samara D. Johnson University of South Carolina
  • Kevin N. Schoell University of South Carolina
  • Zachary K Winkelmann University of South Carolina



Diagnostic Testing and Physical Examination: Lower Extremity


The knee is the most commonly injured joint in sport, inherently meaning the knee is also the joint most frequently evaluated by healthcare providers. Clinicians evaluate and treat the knee as efficiently as possible to prevent long-term disability of the patient. Clinicians rely on physical examination tests such as McMurray’s Test, Apley’s Test, Joint Line Tenderness, Lachman Test, Anterior Drawer, Pivot Shift Test, and the Ottawa Knee Rules for initial diagnosis and initiation of care. These physical examination tests have varying levels of diagnostic accuracy and validity. Clinicians should know how definite they can be about a diagnosis from physical examination alone based on the tests’ validity and reliability. The purpose of this evidence to practice review was to evaluate the validity of the individual and combinations of two or more selective tissue tests for the knee. The authors included systematic reviews and meta-analyses that reported on the diagnostic properties of one or more physical tests for one or more knee disorders. The 17 articles used were screened independently by two reviewers. Each article was appraised using the Assessment of the Methodological Quality of Systematic Reviews (AMSTAR) ranking system. Articles with the highest AMSTAR ranking for each injury and evaluated the sensitivity, specificity, positive likelihood ratio, negative likelihood ratio, and diagnostic odds ratio were used to make recommendations for validity. Physical examination tests of the knee included in the review were found to be most accurate when performed in combination with each other, as they had only low to moderate diagnostic properties. Physical examination tests for the meniscus, ACL, PCL, patellofemoral pain, and knee osteoarthritis are not valid to be used as individual diagnostic tests. The only exemption to this finding is the Lachman test; with a sensitivity of 85%, the Lachman test is suitable to rule out an ACL tear as a stand-alone test.






Evidence to Practice Reviews

Most read articles by the same author(s)

1 2 3 > >>